Ron DeSantis continues to repeat the claim that Disney doesn't want to pay taxes and receives favorable treatment

By WDWMAGIC Staff · Thursday April 27, 2023 11:40am ET · "The Walt Disney Company"
Ron DeSantis continues to repeat the claim that Disney doesn't want to pay taxes and receives favorable treatment
Add WDWMAGIC on Google See more of our stories in Google Top Stories and Discover.
Walt Disney Company headquarters in Burbank, California

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has today responded to Disney filing a major lawsuit against him and the entire board of his hand-picked Central Florida Tourism Oversight District.

Following the same pattern of behavior that the Florida Governor has exhibited in his attacks on Disney over the last year, he repeated claims that Disney doesn't follow the same rules as everyone else and is put on a pedestal.

DeSantis frequently talks about Disney not paying its fair share of taxes and how that will change under his new oversight district. Disney points out that in 2022, it paid $1.146 billion in state and local taxes, making the Walt Disney Company the largest single taxpayer in Central Florida.

Speaking to media during a visit to Israel, DeSantis said, "They're upset because they're having to live by the same rules as everybody else. They don't want to pay the same taxes as everybody else and they want to be able to control things without proper oversight. The days of putting one company on a pedestal with no accountability are over in the state of Florida."

Disney claims in its lawsuit filed in a federal court yesterday that there has been "A targeted campaign of government retaliation-orchestrated at every step by Governor DeSantis as punishment for Disney's protected speech-now threatens Disney's business operations, jeopardizes its economic future in the region, and violates its constitutional rights."

Read more about Disney's lawsuit against Florida Governor Ron DeSantis.

Google

Conversation

25,669 comments
Discuss on the Forums
↩ replying to The Moles Family
Director Krennic actually built something.
↩ replying to The Moles Family
It’s absolutely fair when it’s self inflicted.
If Disney wins this, and all their demands are met what happens exactly?

“Declare that House Bill 4C and House Bill 9C are unlawful and unenforceable because they were enacted in retaliation for Disney’s political speech in violation of the First Amendment”

This is suggesting a full roll back of the initial Reedy Creek dissolution bill. What does that look like in practice the state just picks up and leaves? Old board members are reinstated new politics rolled back?

Or are we only talking about the developer agreement as it is also listed in the lawsuit?

What stops the state from trying to do this again? If Disney wins the suit can they stop that from happening?
↩ replying to MagicHappens1971
I don’t see how it’s “unrelated” at all…

You want to talk about avoiding wages and taxes…lake nona is the poster child for it.

They should cancel it immediately…should have already, actually.
↩ replying to Surferboy567
I wondering about this too.

They can’t actually have a court order “reinstate” a legislative act that was dissolved…so it’s a bigger mess than we are even giving it credit for…

I suppose it can be declared unconstitutional? But that leaves future shenanigans open

This is why you never “pull on the string”
↩ replying to Surferboy567
I believe it would effectively reinstate RCID as it was.

All hypotheticals, but it’s been theorized that a judge could issue a “cooling down” period where the legislature would be unable to do anything regarding RCID for X amount of time. The legislature also would not be able to do the exact same thing they just did (to my understanding) if Disney wins. The suit is also trying to have the legislatures void of the developers agreement overturned as well. It could be said they don’t really care about the development agreement because if they win they don’t need it. Just doesn’t make sense to sue multiple times, so they put everything in there.
↩ replying to Sirwalterraleigh
I think Disney can see the day Ron is the former and they still want to cut wages so they proceed as planned repeating all the while " this too shall pass "
↩ replying to JoeCamel
I think that’s the obvious hedge.

But it’s still slimey and looks bad
↩ replying to mkt
Disney is assisted by a high flying law firm from NY to represent them in fighting DeSantis. One of the firm’s other clients lives in Palm Beach who is also very critical of DeSantis.
↩ replying to ParentsOf4
My complete hypothetical is the suit had prepped over the last few months, arguments tailored for - if not each, then almost every - judge up through SCOTUS.

If you told me half this doc was being fine-tuned on Dropbox six months ago, I would 100% believe that.
↩ replying to Surferboy567
If the judge agrees to that remedy, yes. It may not be the same board, but the landowners could then elect a new or the same board.

As suggested above, I could see the judge ordering a "cooling off" period of a decade or longer.

Yes they can. The act was dissolved by the new bill. If the new bill is declared unconstitutional, then everything, including its repeal of the old act, is void.
A number of 1A attorneys weigh in that they feel Disney has a very strong case.

https://www.cnn.com/2023/04/27/media/ron-desantis-disney-reliable-sources/index.html
@Sirwalterraleigh mentioned this yesterday, but here's the source. Federalist society lawyer thinks Disney has a solid 1A case.

https://www.rawstory.com/ron-desantis-2659917138/
↩ replying to mikejs78
Yeah…I “thought Better” of that…
But it doesn’t mean they can’t try another tactic…maybe even with some thought this time 😎
When it comes to resolution, the judge can issue an order that the dissolution was unconstitutional and roll back. Then have the 2 parties come up with a plan moving forward and enter it as a consent agreement. ie The state agrees to let RCID elect a new board and that it will not attempt to dissolve it or reconstitute it for X years. Then the state and Disney would be bound by the terms of the Consent Decree